There is a phrase that makes experienced real estate professionals cringe: “Let’s just submit a lowball offer and see what happens.”
It sounds low-risk. It sounds like “testing the waters.” But in reality, “seeing what happens” is the most expensive mistake a buyer can make. When a Palm Springs mid-century home has been sitting on the market for 100, 150, or 200 days, it is tempting to think the seller is desperate. Buyers often assume the owner will take anything just to move on.
In most cases, they won’t.
An agent’s job isn’t just to facilitate paperwork; it is to protect the buyer’s leverage. Nothing destroys that leverage faster than an offer that ignores the reality of human psychology and market positioning.
When an offer is submitted at more than 10% below the asking price, it rarely starts a negotiation. Instead, it can start a conflict. Here is what could happen:
Which of those three are you prepared for?
A buyer views the purchase as a business transaction—a set of numbers on a spreadsheet. For the seller, however, the property represents equity, years of memories, and personal ego.
A lowball offer transforms a professional negotiation into an emotional standoff. The moment a seller feels insulted, the “math” stops mattering. They stop thinking about their mortgage and start thinking about how much they dislike the person trying to “undervalue” their home. Once the agent loses the seller’s respect for the client, the buyer loses their seat at the table.
Buyers often believe that a listing with 100+ days on the market (DOM) signals total desperation.
The truth is often the opposite: a seller who hasn’t dropped their price significantly after several months is likely stubborn, not desperate. They have already dug their heels in. If an agent hits them with a lowball offer, they aren’t offering the seller a way out—they are confirming the seller’s suspicion that the market is full of “low-ballers” who don’t appreciate the home’s value.
Strategic positioning is about finding the line where the seller feels the “pinch” of the market but still feels respected enough to engage. If that line is crossed, the seller doesn’t negotiate; they dismiss.
A common misconception is that an agent’s role is to simply relay whatever number the buyer suggests. This is a fundamental misunderstanding of high-level brokerage.
If an agent allows a client to submit an offer that will clearly be rejected out of hand, that agent has failed their client. The agent’s strategic responsibility is to:
A counter-offer is gold. It is a formal, legal commitment from the seller to sell at a specific price. A lowball offer usually results in no counter-offer, which leaves the buyer with zero control over the situation.
To secure a property for the best possible price, an agent must move the client away from “testing the waters” to a strategic plan:
“Seeing what happens” usually results in seeing the house sold to someone else weeks later for a price the original buyer would have happily paid.
An agent’s role is to prevent an emotional reaction from a seller from costing the buyer the home they want. Proper strategy ensures the deal stays alive and the keys end up in the buyer’s hand.
While the market time suggests the price doesn’t align with current buyer demand, it doesn’t automatically mean the seller is ready to accept a deep discount. Often, properties sit because the seller is firm on a specific number. A lowball offer usually confirms their belief that buyers are “bottom-feeding,” causing them to dig their heels in further. The goal is to use data to justify a fair market price that moves the seller, rather than an arbitrary low number that insults them.
A non-response is the most difficult position for a buyer because you lose all leverage. Without a counter-offer, you have no “hook” in the deal and no legal commitment from the seller to sell at any price. In real estate negotiation, silence is a deal-killer. It’s better to submit an offer that is aggressive but realistic enough to force the seller to respond with a counter-offer, which keeps the conversation alive.
This is a common “flea market” strategy that rarely works in high-stakes real estate. If the initial gap is too wide (typically more than 10%), the seller often perceives the buyer as “unserious” or “difficult.” Once a seller labels you as a difficult buyer, they become less likely to grant concessions later during the inspection or appraisal periods. Starting with a strategic, data-backed offer builds the professional rapport needed to win the deal.
The difference lies in the justification. A savvy negotiator uses comparable sales, current market trends, and property condition reports to support their price. A “lowball” is typically an arbitrary number based on what a buyer wants to pay rather than what the market dictates. Your agent will help you find the “sweet spot”—the lowest possible price that still commands respect and a counter-offer from the seller.
SHARE THIS POST
ABOUT THE AUTHOR